Crackerbox Palace: ‘Asylum’ (1972)

❉ We check into Dunsmoor for tales that witness madness…

After a strictly limited special edition release from Second Sight last year, the classic Amicus anthology Asylum is back on Blu-Ray alongside The House That Dripped Blood, which we talked about here.

1972’s Asylum was the fifth of Amicus studios’ ‘portmanteau’ horrors, as they’re known to genre fans, and by now the house style had been pretty well established, proving to be popular and lucrative – Asylum went in front of the cameras barely a month after Tales From The Crypt opened in the UK, and was itself in UK cinemas three months later.

As with the previously reviewed The House That Dripped Blood, Asylum is one of the stand-out entries in the Amicus canon due in part to its use of a distinctive, singular locale for its framework, giving the film a certain cohesion unifying its individual ‘chapters’. In this case it’s the foreboding, grey-walled asylum of the title, Dunsmoor, a permanent home for the ‘incurably insane’, where young Dr. Martin – the lean, intense Robert Powell, fresh from Doomwatch duties – is put through an offbeat job interview by the asylum’s owner, Lionel Rutherford (A lugubrious Patrick Magee), wheelchair-bound after an attack by one of his residents… Chaperoned by attendant Max Reynolds (Geoffrey Bayldon, in a role originally intended for Spike Milligan!), Martin is invited to meet four patients and hear their tragic stories and must deduce which one of them is the mysterious ‘Dr Starr’, the asylum’s previous manager, and now a patient after a “complete mental breakdown”.

Like The House That Dripped Blood, the individual chapters are written by the film’s scriptwriter Robert (Psycho) Bloch, adapting short stories Bloch had originally written for pulp fiction magazines – one of these had also been adapted for TV in the Alfred Hitchcock Mystery Hour – and in true Amicus style, these chips off the old Bloch are brought to the screen with a mostly British cast of familiar faces ranging from veteran character actors Magee, Bayldon, Barry Morse, Richard Todd, Herbert Lom and James Villiers to rising stars of the ‘70s Robert Powell, Britt Ekland and Charlotte Rampling, whose iconic gigs Tommy, The Man With the Golden Gun and The Night Porter respectively were just around the corner. And of course, it wouldn’t be an Amicus movie without the gentleman of horror, Peter Cushing. The real star of Asylum, however, is classical composer Mussorgsky, whose pounding, pealing suites are plastered over the film’s soundtrack to great effect in the various vignettes.

Peter Cushing in Asylum (1972)

The stories which comprise Asylum – indeed, a film called Asylum – would not play well with advocates of a more enlightened approach to mental health issues, but they take place on a different plane altogether to any realistic portrayal of sanity or lack thereof. But ‘Civilised’ folk will always have a morbid fascination with peering into the abyss to see our own reflection, and these macabre tales are deliberately heightened nightmares of extremes of the human condition.

Barbara Parkins in Asylum (1972)

The poor souls who feature in Asylum’s vignettes are not victims of ‘insanity’, but an altogether more relatable condition – obsession, whether it’s the cast of The Weird Tailor, from Barry Morse’s poverty stricken tailor and his client Peter Cushing’s very specific requirements for a mysterious suit made of eldtrich fabrics to the tailor’s daughter becoming besotted with the suit’s mannequin, to the frankly bonkers Mannikins Of Horror, where Herbert Lom is working on a tiny automata replica of himself that can be animated by his own will in order to take revenge on Rutherford, or opening instalment Frozen Fear, a fun, if predictable, revenge tale of sexual betrayal and jealousy and brown paper packages tied up with strings….

Frozen Fear and The Weird Tailor almost feel like escapees from previous Amicus anthologies – the former calls to mind aspects of The Vault of Horror’s The Neat Job, while The Weird Tailor feels like a leftover from Dr. Terror’s House of Horrors or Torture Garden, with the rather creaky, claustrophobic vibe of those early Amicus’ efforts less well realised chapters, and Peter Cushing while admittedly watchable as always, isn’t seen at his best in an underwritten role he could play in his sleep – less said about the risible Jewish caricature Barry Morse has to work with the better, despite the sympathy his character engenders.

Britt Ekland in Asylum (1972)

The real highlights of the film come from its third and fourth chapters, Lucy Comes To Stay and Mannikins of Horror. The former is a rather poignant tale with (spoiler alert!) Charlotte Rampling and Britt Ekland playing twin sides of the same woman’s psyche – Barbara (Rampling) has just been released from hospital suffering from some kind of breakdown, but enjoys no sense of freedom as she is zombified with medication by her nurse (Megs Jenkins) and over-protected by her brother George (James Villiers). All this changes when Lucy (Ekland) comes to stay, endeavouring to persuade Barbara to loosen her shackles so they can get up to mischief together as they did before Barbara’s hospitalisation…

The contrast between Rampling and Ekland makes for perfect casting here, with Rampling at her most protean and androgynous in appearance, playing Barbara with the same sort of distracted, somnambulant quality as Catherine Deneuve in Repulsion, while blonde, girlish Ekland is bright as a button as the coquettish, flighty ‘naughty little sister’ figure. It’s an at times haunting and affecting vignette, which closes with a well realised mirror gag.

One can’t help but wonder if this instalment inspired Richard Matheson’s Millicent and Therese, the middle story of Karen Black vehicle Trilogy of Terror (1975).

Asylum (1972)

The closing tale, Mannikins of Terror, brings the storyline back to the titular setting in fine fashion with a wonderfully absurd yarn about a miniature homunculus crafted by Byron – Herbert Lom on top glowering form as an ‘inmate’ of equal intellectual stature to his ‘capture’ Rutherford, toiling over his will-powered, part-organic robotic minifig of terror to exact revenge on Magee. The scenario is, of course, daft as a brush, but like many of Amicus’ grim fairy tales, the fact that it is played dead straight by all involved makes for a captivating flight of delirium and obsession.

But who was Dr. Starr? You’ll have to check-in to Dunsmoor to find out!

After many years existing on home media as a poor quality transfer, this spectacular clean up of the original 16mm film – gotta love that early ‘70s film grain, showing the location in all its grim, whitewashed seediness – scrubs up a treat, and is complemented by a raft of extras including those ported over from previous Region 1 and 2 releases, including a genuine time-capsule in the form of a BBC on-location report with cast and crew. As standard, the sleeve insert comes with an option for the owner to display the original one-sheet poster art or Graham Humphreys’ new artwork, in the genre poster artist’s trademark ghoulish hues. With Second Sight’s pairing of Asylum and The House That Dripped Blood, and Indicator’s handsomely presented Blu-Ray of Torture Garden, it’s to be hoped that the entire canon of Amicus anthologies can soon be enjoyed anew in HD.


 Audio Commentary with director Roy Ward Baker and camera operator Neil Binney
 ‘Two’s a Company’: 1972 on-set BBC report featuring interviews with producer Milton Subotsky, Director Roy Ward Baker, Actors Charlotte Rampling, James Villiers, Megs Jenkins, Art Director Tony Curtis and Production Manager Teresa Bolland
 Screenwriter David J. Schow on writer Robert Bloch
 Fiona Subotsky remembers Milton Subotsky
 ‘Inside The Fear Factory’ Featurette with directors Roy Ward Baker, Freddie Francis and producer Max J. Rosenberg
 Theatrical trailer
 Reversible sleeve featuring new artwork by Graham Humphreys and original artwork
 SDH English subtitles for the hard of hearing

❉ Asylum Standard Edition Blu-ray (2NDBR4116) released on 6 January 2019. Running Time: 88 mins Region: B Cert: 15. RRP £15.99. Click here to buy directly from Second Sight Films.

❉ Check out Second Sight Films’ new website for new release info and for consumers to buy direct at More from Second Sight Films here: Twitter Instagram Facebook

 James Gent is the Editor of We Are Cult, and is the co-editor of Me and the Starman, (Chinbeard Books, 2019) Available in paperback from Amazon: All profits from this book go toward supporting the work of Cancer Research UK.

Become a patron at Patreon!

1 Comment

  1. Asylum really does take insanity to another level. And is really scary, when i first saw it at age 13 it wasnt to be taken lightly as it had an impact on me. I believe its known as fear or shock, but i still remember the next day in school we were all talking about it for hours. And this was in 1986. Its the best or 1 of the best horror films i have ever seen. And i havent seen better since. Its terrifieying on all levels. And some of it like the tailor who made suits and herbert lom making a toy soldier do what he wanted and that was to kill dr rutherford who owned the asylum, i thought that just took it a bit far and the manniquien walking about the shop on fire. Tales 2 and 4 just went to far imo. But in a mad way still great. It really is a true british classic. And the bbc dont use those words often. It gets a 10 out of 10 from me. And what was that cast like alone? Just great. You wont ever see films like that again so i hope the bbc keep that film forever.

Comments are closed.